SCI论文审稿意见案例及回复模板,这篇指南值得收藏!
发布网友
发布时间：2024-10-07 10:00
共1个回答
热心网友
时间：2024-12-14 08:29
1. 实验设计和方法学问题
意见：审稿人提出对实验设计的疑虑，认为样本量较小，建议增加实验的重复次数。
解决方法：作者在回复中详细解释了样本量选择的原因，并接受了审稿人的建议，增加了额外的实验，并在修改后的论文中加入了新的实验结果。
2. 数据解释和结果分析问题
意见：审稿人指出对于某个实验结果的解释不够清晰，建议提供更详细的数据解释和统计分析。
解决方法：作者在回复中补充了对该实验结果的解释，并在修改后的论文中增加了更详细的统计分析，以支持他们的主张。
3. 文献综述和背景问题
意见：审稿人认为文献综述缺乏对最新研究的覆盖，并建议作者添加对最新进展的讨论。
解决方法：作者在修改后的论文中加入了最新研究的相关细节，同时在文献综述中增加了对当前领域进展的更全面的描述。
4. 逻辑结构和组织性问题
意见：审稿人指出论文结构不够清晰，建议重新组织段落以提高整体逻辑性。
解决方法：作者在回复中解释了论文结构的考虑因素，并在修改后的版本中重新安排了一些段落，以确保论文的逻辑结构更为清晰。
5. 讨论 и заключение
意见：审稿人认为讨论部分缺乏深度，建议对实验结果的潜在影响进行更全面的探讨。
解决方法：作者在回复中补充了对实验结果潜在影响的深入讨论，并扩展了讨论部分以更好地回应审稿人的建议。
如何回应小修和大修的审稿意见
在向SCI期刊投稿的过程中，接受审稿是提高论文质量和学术水平的关键环节。审稿意见通常分为小修和大修，需要作者对论文进行一些修改。以下是针对小修和大修的审稿意见的回复模板：
小修订的回复
1. 感谢审稿人的建议：
We appreciate the thoughtful review and constructive feedback provided by the reviewers.
2. 明确接受建议：
We agree with the reviewers' suggestions and will incorporate the recommended changes into the manuscript.
3. 逐条回应：
Reviewer 1 suggested improving the clarity of Figure 3. We will revise the figure to enhance readability, and we appreciate the valuable suggestion.
4. 展示修改：
In response to the comment about the literature review, we have added references XXXX et al. (2022) and provided a brief discussion, as suggested (see revised pages 4-5).
5. 再次感谢：
We sincerely appreciate the time and effort invested by the reviewers in evaluating our manuscript. We look forward to any additional feedback or suggestions.
大修订的回复
1. 理解审稿人的关切：
We appreciate the reviewers' thorough evaluation and recognize the major concerns raised regarding the clarity of our main argument and the completeness of the theoretical framework.
2. 接受建议并展望未来：
We acknowledge the need for major revisions and are committed to addressing the highlighted issues comprehensively. We believe that these revisions will significantly strengthen our manuscript and provide a more robust foundation for our claims.
3. 详细说明修改计划：
3.1. Clarification of Main Argument:
We plan to restructure the Introction and Discussion sections to provide a more lucid presentation of our main argument. Specific attention will be given to...
3.2. Enhancement of Theoretical Framework:
To address the concerns raised about the theoretical framework, we will conct an in-depth literature analysis and incorporate relevant writings on...
4. 明确的时间表：
We aim to complete the major revisions by [specific date], and we will promptly resubmit the revised manuscript for your kind consideration.
5. 再次感谢：
We are grateful for the invaluable feedback provided by the reviewers, and we look forward to the opportunity to improve our manuscript in response to their guidance.
其他SCI审稿意见回复
1.审稿人提出「图中需要补充比例尺」回复:
we have incorporated the requested scale bars to enhance the clarity of the images.
2.审稿人提出「部分图片没有显著性差异」回复:
we have denoted significant differences with asterisks in the figures.
3.审稿人提出「补充缩写词的全称」回复：
Addressing the reviewer's comment, comprehensive descriptions for abbreviations like lHC, MTT, etc., have been added to the revised manuscript.
如果您有SCI论文润色需求或任何发表问题欢迎咨询我哦~
